Notary Mistakes That Destroy Careers: 4 Real Cases Every Client Should Know About

Most people think notarizing a document is simple. A quick stamp, a signed paper, and you are done. But behind that stamp is legal responsibility that carries real consequences. One mistake can not only ruin a notary’s career, it can also lead to lawsuits, financial damage, or even criminal charges.

As a professional notary serving Washington State, I take this part of my job seriously. And for good reason. There are real cases involving real notaries who thought shortcuts or favors were no big deal. The results were devastating for them and the people they meant to help.

Here are four true stories that show exactly why notary laws exist and why following them is not optional.

📝 Case 1. Parking Lot Deed Scam in Ohio

A notary in Ohio agreed to notarize four property deeds in a parking lot. She had never seen the homeowners and took someone else’s word that the signatures were legitimate. Those same documents were used to steal the homes from their rightful owners.

When the scam was exposed, the criminals went to prison and the notary was charged with four felony counts of tampering. She lost her notary commission and her business.

The mistake. Not verifying identity and notarizing without the signers present.

📝 Case 2. The Disbarred North Carolina Attorney

A North Carolina attorney who was also a notary became involved in two fraudulent notarizations. She notarized paperwork with signatures from people who never appeared before her.

One of those documents allowed a house to be sold without the real heir’s permission. She said the mistakes were innocent. The court saw them as deliberate. She was disbarred, convicted, and forced to give up her law career.

The mistake. Not requiring the signer to be in the room and ignoring warning signs.

📝 Case 3. Accepting a Photocopied ID in California

A California notary accepted a photocopy of an ID instead of a real one. The signer was later exposed as an imposter committing mortgage fraud. The title company sued the notary for one hundred eighty thousand dollars.

The case was eventually settled for twenty five thousand dollars, which still could have destroyed the notary financially if they did not have errors and omissions insurance.

The mistake. Accepting a copy of an ID instead of verifying a valid, physical identification.

📝 Case 4. Missing Thumbprint, Six Figure Lawsuit

Another notary in California was handling a real estate signing. California law requires a thumbprint for certain notarizations involving property. The notary failed to collect one. The signer was later revealed to be a con artist.

The title company sued the notary for two hundred fifty thousand dollars because the missing thumbprint would have exposed the fraud. Errors and omissions insurance eventually covered fifty thousand dollars of the settlement.

The mistake. Skipping a required step because it seemed minor.

💡 The Lesson Behind Every Case

Notary work is not just stamping paper. Every notarization carries legal weight and responsibility. A notary who skips ID checks, ignores legal requirements, or rushes through an appointment is risking more than a mistake. They are risking their career, their reputation, and the safety of the people they serve.

A good notary protects the public. A careless notary can help commit fraud without ever intending to.

So if a notary asks to see your ID in person, requires a thumbprint, or refuses to notarize something that “seems harmless,” this is the reason. One tiny shortcut can destroy a life, a career, or someone’s home.

🔍 Need a Notary Who Follows the Rules Every Time?

I am a mobile and online notary serving Washington State, including Pierce County, Thurston County, and parts of Lewis County. I follow every law and standard so your documents and your peace of mind stay fully protected.

I am also pet friendly, flexible, and here to make the process calm, smooth, and professional.

✨ Girl Friday Notary Services

Notarization may be boring but I'm not!