Notary Fraud Is No Joke: 3 Real Cases That Changed Everything

When most people think about notary fraud, they picture forged signatures or maybe a botched ID check. What they do not imagine is murder, stolen property, or families devastated by crimes that could have been stopped with a simple refusal to notarize.

But that is the reality.

Notary fraud is not just a paperwork issue. It is a real threat that has destroyed lives and careers and it is often the result of someone bending a rule, skipping a step, or trying to “be helpful.”

Below are three true crime cases that every notary and every person signing important documents should know about. Because the consequences of not following notary law can go far beyond a lawsuit or a revoked commission.

1️⃣ The Disappearance of Irene Silverman (1998)

Irene Silverman was a wealthy New York socialite whose life took a tragic turn when a mother and son con team, Sante and Kenneth Kimes, targeted her. Their plan was to impersonate Silverman, steal her multi million dollar property, and vanish with the proceeds.

They met with two notaries.

• One notary refused because the identification did not seem legitimate

• The other agreed to notarize blank affidavits without the signer present

The second notary’s failure to follow the law became a link in the chain that allowed the Kimes duo to steal and eventually murder Silverman. The notary was not charged with the crime, but their lapse in judgment played a direct role in the scheme.

2️⃣ The Yacht Murder of Thomas and Jackie Hawks (2004)

Retired couple Thomas and Jackie Hawks decided to sell their yacht and start a new chapter in life. They met with buyer Skylar Deleon, a former child actor turned criminal.

A notary later claimed to have met with the couple and notarized the yacht transfer paperwork. That turned out to be a lie.

The Hawks had already been murdered at sea by Deleon and his accomplices, who tied them to an anchor and threw them overboard. The forged, falsely notarized documents were an attempt to steal the yacht and cover up the crime.

That fraudulent notarization became key evidence in the investigation. Deleon is now on death row. The notary was not physically involved in the killing, but her dishonesty became part of the case forever.

3️⃣ The Palm Springs Murder of Cliff Lambert (2008)

Palm Springs resident Cliff Lambert was murdered by people he trusted, including a real estate broker named David Replogle. Their goal was to take control of Lambert’s home and assets.

Posing as Lambert, Replogle signed and notarized property documents in front of a notary and even left a thumbprint in the notary’s journal. Later, he tried to steal the journal to cover his tracks. That attempt failed and the notary’s journal became critical evidence that helped convict him.

This case proves why accurate journals and identity checks are not optional. They can help solve crimes and protect victims long after the document is signed.

⚠️ The Modern Threat: AI and Identity Fraud

If these cases feel like something from the past, consider this. Criminals today are using artificial intelligence to create fake IDs, synthetic voices, and video deepfakes. The Federal Trade Commission is actively working to regulate AI impersonation because fraudsters now have digital tools that make deception even easier.

That means notaries must be even more vigilant. Remote online notarization, electronic ID verification, and biometric authentication are becoming essential parts of fraud prevention.

💡 The Real Lesson

A notary’s best defense against fraud is not complicated. It is consistency.

• Require personal appearance every time

• Verify identity properly

• Document every act in a detailed journal

• Trust your instincts and stop the signing if something feels wrong

Every tragedy in these stories began with a notary who bent the rules. That is why following state law is not paperwork or protocol. It is protection.

Notary fraud is real. It involves real people. And it carries real consequences.

✨ Girl Friday Notary Services

Notarization may be boring but I'm not!

Professional, pet friendly, mobile and online notary serving Pierce, Thurston and parts of Lewis Counties in Washington State. Here to make the legal parts of life calm, safe, and honest.